September 11th, 2014
Is This Trial Ethical?
CardioExchange Editors, Staff
Last month, an article appeared in The Telegraph (U.K.) describing a randomized trial in which cardiac arrest patients will be assigned to receive epinephrine or placebo during resuscitation.
Current ALCS guidelines contain a Class IIb, level A recommendation for administration of epinephrine for sustained VF and PEA/asystole but acknowledge that although epinephrine treatment has been demonstrated to increase rates of return of spontaneous circulation, it has not been shown to improve long-term survival.
This is not the first time epinephrine and placebo have been compared in a randomized trial; results of such a trial appeared in Resuscitation in 2011. Nonetheless, the new trial appears to have sparked ethical concerns about its delayed-consent procedure.
What do you think? Would you support such a trial in your EMS system?
Categories: General
Tags: advanced cardiac life support, cardiac arrest, epinephrine, informed consent, resuscitation
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.
Comments are closed.
Search the Archive
Archives by Date
NEJM — Recent Cardiology Articles- Reducing Tobacco Use Worldwide: The Epidemic of Tobacco Harms among People with Mental Health Conditions December 13, 2025High rates of tobacco use among people with mental health conditions contribute to their increased morbidity and mortality, but tobacco cessation interventions can be effective in this population.
- How to Save a Life December 13, 2025When his longtime friend has a myocardial infarction, a physician notes that decades of medical research contributed to saving his life. What will save lives after research funding has been decimated?
- Immeasurable Excellence — What Happens to Medicine without the “Good Doctor”? December 11, 2025The true value of primary care may elude modern medicine’s metrics, but PCPs have long embodied the ethos of the “good doctor.” Should the rest of the medical profession step up to save them?
- Aortic Intramural Hematoma December 11, 2025An 80-year-old man presented to the emergency department with a 12-hour history of pleuritic chest pain and an elevated d-dimer level. A CT scan showed an ulcerlike projection in the ascending thoracic aorta.
- High-Dose Influenza Vaccine Effectiveness against Hospitalization in Older Adults December 11, 2025Among adults 65 years of age or older, a high-dose influenza vaccine did not result in a significantly lower incidence of hospitalization for influenza or pneumonia than a standard-dose vaccine.
- Reducing Tobacco Use Worldwide: The Epidemic of Tobacco Harms among People with Mental Health Conditions December 13, 2025
-
Tag Cloud
- ACS AF AHA anticoagulation aortic valve replacement apixaban aspirin atrial fibrillation CABG cardiovascular risk cholesterol clopidogrel dabigatran diabetes diet drug-eluting stents epidemiology ESC exercise FDA FDA approvals Fellowship training guidelines HDL heart failure hypertension ICDs MI myocardial infarction obesity PCI Primary PCI risk factors rivaroxaban statins STEMI stents stroke stroke prevention TAVI TAVR type 2 diabetes venous thromboembolism warfarin women
