May 20th, 2014
Hopes and Beliefs: How Patients Respond to Informed-Consent Tools
Todd K. Rosengart, MD
In an article recently published in Annals of Thoracic Surgery, investigators describe results of a randomized comparison of two different instruments for providing informed consent to 240 patients scheduled for elective cardiac catheterization with possible PCI: a scripted verbal or written presentation and a commercially available, web-based, audiovisual presentation (provided for free by the developer). They found that although both instruments significantly increased patient understanding in two of three key domains (risks and alternatives), the audiovisual instrument outperformed the verbal or written instrument only in the identification of alternative treatments, and neither instrument significantly increased patient understanding of the benefits of the procedure.
CardioExchange Editor-in-Chief Harlan Krumholz discusses the findings with the paper’s senior author, Todd Rosengart, MD.
Harlan Krumholz: The paper is quite interesting. What surprised you most about your findings?
Todd Rosengart: We were amazed that so many patients still heard and believed what they were most hopeful for, such as that PCI would “cure their disease,” especially when corrective counter-information was provided. We were surprised, despite some improvements provided by the audiovisual consent process, that the outcomes were not even better. It taught us that the information provided in the consent tool needs to be carefully thought through to deliver the intended message.
Krumholz: Why didn’t you enroll more patients?
Rosengart: Timing issues led to our termination of the study earlier than expected. Given that there were no discernable trends toward an improvement in comprehension with the audiovisual device in most categories beyond those already identified, in part because of the issues noted above, we concluded that outcomes would have remained largely unchanged even with larger enrollment numbers.
Krumholz: Why did you publish this paper in a surgical journal, since the topic was PCI and cath?
Rosengart: Surgeons as well as cardiologist and PCPs have harbored great concerns regarding the success of current PCI consenting processes in adequately informing patients about the risks and benefits of PCI, as well as alternatives to PCI such as surgery. This study was designed to inform the surgical as well as the medical community as to the adequacy of current processes and the availability of potential improvements, such as the tested audiovisual consenting tool.
Krumholz: What do you believe are the main reasons that patients have misperceptions? We published a paper on this a decade ago; in 2010, Rothberg and colleagues repeated it and found the same results. Both were single-center studies, but the results were the same — decades apart. Why is this so?
Rosengart: As you know, this has been the subject of much investigation — including psychological analyses. It is interesting that aspirational goals (“this will make me better”) are less well-conceptualized (overestimated) than potential risks, which were relatively well understood. As noted in the paper, this seems to correlate well with physicians’ own well-documented inflated perceptions of procedural benefits as well as with the psychology of wanting to feel and be “better.” All of the above underline the need for diligent, objective transfer of information.
Krumholz: Why didn’t this intervention work? What did it make you think of the product that is being sold?
Rosengart: As noted above, our data highlighted the need for further improvements and expansion of information conveyed in such products, which we believe can be effective if so enhanced.
Krumholz: What are the next steps?
Rosengart: Further improvements in the informational content of the audiovisual tool have been recommended. We look forward to further testing of such tools.
Categories: General
Tags: informed consent, Interventional Cardiology, patient expectations, patient-physician interaction, PCI
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. Both comments and pings are currently closed.
3 Responses to “Hopes and Beliefs: How Patients Respond to Informed-Consent Tools”
-
Search the Archive
Archives by Date
NEJM — Recent Cardiology Articles- Extended Outcomes of the ADAPT AF-DES Trial November 19, 2026In patients with atrial fibrillation and a stent placed at least 1 year earlier, non–vitamin K antagonist oral anticoagulant monotherapy resulted in fewer net adverse clinical events at 2 years than a NOAC plus clopidogrel.
- Aspirin Omission at the Time of Primary Percutaneous Coronary Intervention in STEMI November 19, 2026Among patients with STEMI, prasugrel monotherapy initiated before PCI was not noninferior to dual antiplatelet therapy with prasugrel plus aspirin for a composite of death, stroke, or myocardial infarction at 12 months.
- Expanding the Evidence and Indications for Thrombectomy in Ischemic Stroke November 19, 2026In 2015, pivotal randomized, controlled trials established the benefit of endovascular treatment for acute ischemic stroke due to a large-vessel occlusion.1,2 The trials showed a major clinical benefit in patients presenting with relatively standard stroke features: large-vessel occlusion in the anterior circulation; relevant clinical neurologic deficit; short time...
- Too Soon to Say Goodbye — Aspirin at the Door in STEMI November 19, 2026The 19th-century English biologist Thomas H. Huxley once said, “The great tragedy of Science — the slaying of a beautiful hypothesis by an ugly fact.” For as long as many can recall, aspirin has been the first drug administered for the treatment of ST-segment elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI), often in...
- Mechanical Thrombectomy 24 to 72 Hours after Large-Vessel Ischemic Stroke November 19, 2026Among patients with salvageable tissue 24 to 72 hours after stroke, physical function at 90 days was better with thrombectomy than with medical care alone, but intracerebral hemorrhage and death were more common with thrombectomy.
- Extended Outcomes of the ADAPT AF-DES Trial November 19, 2026
-
Tag Cloud
- ACS AF AHA anticoagulation aortic valve replacement apixaban aspirin atrial fibrillation CABG cardiovascular risk cholesterol clopidogrel dabigatran diabetes diet drug-eluting stents epidemiology ESC exercise FDA FDA approvals Fellowship training guidelines HDL heart failure hypertension ICDs MI myocardial infarction obesity PCI Primary PCI risk factors rivaroxaban statins STEMI stents stroke stroke prevention TAVI TAVR type 2 diabetes venous thromboembolism warfarin women

Congratulations on an important study. Having not seen the video, I will assume that it went through rigorous development, with feedback from clinicians and patients, and that it is quite decent. So I am not really convinced that the next step should be educational tool improvement. What do you think would be different the next time around, and should better knowledge scores be the goal? Have we advanced the patient’s health, experience, outcomes?
“Doctor House vs Robocop”
Thank you for this nice study and well conducted discussion.
This makes me think that we are only human beings, sharing emotion with our patients.
This is well summarized in the remark of Dr Rosengart “physicians’ perception of procedural benefits” it explains why most of the patients (fortunately) keep in mind the positive of the procedure when explain them on an emphatic way (because we believe it is the good one!) .
A robot without any emotional participation (uniform sight, monochord speech, unchanging gestures…) will probably collect different informed consents.
This can be the subject of a following study.” Informed consent signed in front of Robocop”
In my experience most of the people use a thinking process very different from the one we use after years of study and experience. A great deal of people base their decision on their own experience, advice from family and friends and of course from Internet, not necessarily from scientific evidence, and who can blame them this days you can find scientific evidence in any directions in a lot of subject. Most of the people is susceptible to advertising that’s why is a well known profession. Many people go to the doctor complaining of pain, so nobody likes pain and discomfort so everybody prefer comfortable procedures. At the end for a lot of people their medical decision are and act of faith, they prepare for the worst and hope for the best.