An ongoing dialogue on HIV/AIDS, infectious diseases,
June 19th, 2011
Abacavir Agonistes
The studies on abacavir and its potential association with increased cardiovascular risk have been inconsistent ever since the news first broke at CROI 2008. But recently the data have been swirling around so fast and furious that it seems appropriate to take out this famous Greek epithet.
A summary of some recent notable studies:
- An FDA meta-analysis presented at CROI this year of randomized clinical trials — which avoids selection bias — finds absolutely no association with MI. Note that the analysis includes the studies in this ACTG report, and more.
- By contrast, a newly published observational VA study — including 11,000 patients, mostly men — demonstrates that among HIV therapies, only abacavir is associated with increased risk of cardiovascular events.
- Up in Montreal, here’s another study (n=7,000) with a positive association between abacavir and MI, this time along with several other antiretrovirals (including, oddly, efavirenz — marking the first time an NNRTI has ever been implicated in CV risk, and frankly raising more questions about study result validity than making me worried about efavirenz). Journal Watch coverage here.
- Meanwhile, the original VA abacavir study — the first one to introduce renal disease as an important possible cause of “channeling bias” back in Cape Town — has just been published, and this one includes even more patients (19,000) than the VA study cited above (I presume there’s some overlap). The result? It shows not only no significant association of abacavir with MI, but that abacavir is associated with a reduced risk of cerebrovascular disease (stroke).
- The editorialist commenting on the paper (Sam Bozzette) examines the numbers carefully and — somewhat surprisingly in light of the study findings — writes: “Moreover, the trends tend to support the controversial notion of a differential effect of abacavir [on MI risk]…”
- And what about that protective effect of abacavir on stroke seen in this study? A Danish study found just the opposite: on investigating possible risk factors for stroke among patients with HIV, the researchers showed that abacavir was associated with increased cerebrovascular events — and it was the only HIV treatment to earn this honor.
Got that?
Although it’s tempting to revert to the last refuge of the researcher, grant writer, and journalist — the generic “more research is needed” — I’m pretty sure we’ve reached a point of diminishing returns on these abacavir-cardiovascular disease studies, at least those of retrospective observational design.
And from a practical, day-to-day patient management perspective, in my view nothing really has changed despite these recent studies. It seems advisable to avoid using abacavir in patients with high cardiovascular risk if there are suitable alternatives (which there usually are), but that stable patients already on the drug should remain on it unless there’s a compelling reason to switch.
Paul E. Sax, MD
Associate Editor
NEJM Clinician
Biography | Disclosures & Summaries
Learn more about HIV and ID Observations.
FROM NEJM — Recent Infectious Disease Articles- Shock Not Advised April 30, 2026A physician offers to help in a medical emergency on a transatlantic flight. Though she faces limits of bureaucracy, equipment, and ultimately biology, she discovers her physicianhood is inescapable.
- Pulmonary Tuberculosis Detection with MiniDock MTB Using Swab Samples April 30, 2026Rapid, affordable, and easy-to-use diagnostic testing for tuberculosis is needed. In a multinational study, the accuracy of a tuberculosis diagnostic deployable to peripheral health care centers was assessed.
- Legislating Medicine — Directed Donation and the Politics of Patient Choice April 30, 2026A Tennessee bill focused on directed blood donation exemplifies a pattern of efforts to legislate medical practice in ways that override scientific consensus while invoking the language of autonomy.
- Tackling Maternal Sepsis — Doing the Basics, and Doing Them Well April 30, 2026In the mid-19th century, the Hungarian physician Ignaz Semmelweis’s observations and theories about the transfer of “cadaverous particles” on the hands of doctors led to the development of hygiene protocols, such as hand washing with chlorine, which resulted in a reduction in maternal mortality associated with puerperal fever.1,2 ...
- Case 13-2026: A 76-Year-Old Woman with Fatigue, Rash, and Kidney Failure April 30, 2026A 76-year-old woman, who had a history of treated hepatitis C virus infection, presented with rapidly progressive kidney failure and a stroke. Palpable purpura on the legs was noted. A diagnosis was made.
- Shock Not Advised April 30, 2026