An ongoing dialogue on HIV/AIDS, infectious diseases,
October 3rd, 2011
CASCADE: When to Start, (Yet) Another Take
As we await the enrollment, analysis, and results of the START study — which is randomizing patients with CD4>500 to start HIV therapy vs waiting until the CD4 falls to 350 — much of the research on “when to start” ART in patients with high CD4’s comes from observational studies. Several have already been published (NA-ACCORD, ART-CC, CAUSAL), but one limitation of each of them is that none could accurately assess duration of HIV infection.
Enter “CASCADE“, or “Concerted Action on SeroConversion to AIDS and Death in Europe”. CASCADE includes patients from Europe, Australia, and Canada only if they have a defined date of HIV acquisition, thereby limiting effects of lead-time bias. In order to get at the when-to-start question, the investigators constructed something called “nested subcohorts” between 1996 and 2009, comparing the outcomes of those who started ART vs. those who didn’t.
The results? Out of 9,455 patients, starting ART (vs deferring) was associated with a lower risk of developing AIDS or death for those with a CD4 cell count < 500 — but not for those who started between 500-799. An interesting aspect of this study is that they were able to calculate a “number needed to treat” (NNT) to prevent progression. Over 3 years of follow-up, 21 and 34 patients would need to start treatment to prevent one patient from progressing to AIDS or death in those with CD4s between 200-349 and 350-499 respectively.
Usual caveats of observational studies apply — most notably that no such study can control for all factors between those who started ART vs those who didn’t that would influence outcome — but the results are helpful nonetheless, as the benefits of therapy before the CD4 cell count falls to < 350 shown here have been consistently seen in multiple studies. Furthermore, the NNT data to prevent AIDS or death — 34 for CD4 between 350-499 — place the benefits of treating these patients as even greater than what we accomplish with statin therapy for hypercholesterolemia to prevent MIs, which is estimated as 40-70.
Bottom line: Treating patients with CD4 350-500 and no symptoms may not be as exciting giving ART to someone with advanced HIV disease, but it sure makes good clinical sense.
Paul E. Sax, MD
Associate Editor
NEJM Clinician
Biography | Disclosures & Summaries
Learn more about HIV and ID Observations.
FROM NEJM — Recent Infectious Disease Articles- Postpartum Persistence of Ebola Virus in Breast Milk March 12, 2026To control EBOV outbreaks, defining potential sanctuary sites where the virus may persist and lead to transmission is important. In this report, persistence of EBOV RNA in breast milk was identified and characterized.
- Soft Tick Relapsing Fever March 12, 2026A 74-year-old man was admitted to the hospital with a 3-week history of intermittent fevers, muscle aches, and vomiting. Thin blood smears showed spirochetes.
- Case 8-2026: A 57-Year-Old Woman with Chest Pain, Dyspnea, and Syncope March 12, 2026A 57-year-old woman was evaluated because of 2 days of chest pain and dyspnea. Ultrasonography showed a pericardial effusion with diastolic inversion of the right ventricle. A diagnosis was made.
- Massive Intravascular Hemolysis from Clostridium perfringens Bacteremia March 12, 2026A 73-year-old woman presented in shock with a 1-day history of malaise, dyspnea, and confusion. Serum samples could not be processed owing to gross hemolysis. Dehemoglobinized red cells and bacilli were seen on a peripheral-blood smear.
- The Eyes Have It March 5, 2026A 47-year-old man was brought to the ED by EMS after being found dyspneic in his car. He reported having been drinking for 6 hours before presentation. He noted a sensation of tongue swelling and difficulty breathing.
- Postpartum Persistence of Ebola Virus in Breast Milk March 12, 2026