An ongoing dialogue on HIV/AIDS, infectious diseases,
January 29th, 2009
Too Many Options: What Actually Happened
We recently published a case in AIDS Clinical Care entitled “Too Many Options”, describing a patient with longstanding HIV infection, virologic failure, and resistance to NRTIs, NNRTIs, and PIs.
Fortunately, resistance and tropism testing gave him several options for a new drug regimen — including darunavir, etravirine, maraviroc, enfuvirtide, and — if one believes phenotypic NRTI susceptibility with multiple TAMs — several NRTIs.
And what did our three experts suggest? Three different regimens:
- Sharon Walmsley: darunavir/r, maraviroc, and etravirine (three drugs — not counting ritonavir)
- Tim Wilkin: darunavir/r, raltegravir, maraviroc, and tenofovir/FTC (five drugs)
- Graeme Moyle: darunavir/r, raltegravir, and maraviroc (three drugs, but different from Sharon’s selection)
Now these are smart, highly-experienced clinicians, physicians who are active in clinical research, know the literature extremely well, and actually see patients. (Funny how that last part is sometimes left out.) Each of them provided sound reasons for their (varying) choices.
And what did we do with this patient? (Or one very much like him … obviously some details changed as per HIPAA mandate.)
We offered him the chance to enroll in the clinical study ACTG 5241 (mentioned by Tim), which takes patients like this, gives them an optimal regimen — then randomizes them to receive or not to receive NRTIs.
(I don’t think it will ruin the study to mention that the “flip of the coin” gave him the “No Nukes” option.)
I sure hope we learn something from this study. While we know that regimens should contain “two (preferably three)” active agents, beyond that there’s plenty of uncertainty out there.
2 Responses to “Too Many Options: What Actually Happened”
Paul E. Sax, MD
Associate Editor
NEJM Clinician
Biography | Disclosures & Summaries
Learn more about HIV and ID Observations.
FROM NEJM — Recent Infectious Disease Articles- Subacute Sclerosing Panencephalitis after Measles Infection February 21, 2026A 7-year-old boy was brought to a hospital with a 3-month history of cognitive deterioration and seizures. He had contracted measles at 7 months of age while living in an area where the infection is endemic.
- AI-Enabled Precision-Education Systems — Transforming Lifelong Learning in Medicine February 21, 2026Trainees’ paths to safe, independent practice are variable. Artificial intelligence could help accelerate implementation of competency-based medical education to support individualized development.
- Revival of Ethionamide by Alpibectir February 19, 2026Ethionamide has been used to treat tuberculosis for decades, but dose-dependent toxic effects have limited its use. In this trial, alpibectir enabled the ethionamide dose to be reduced by two thirds.
- Peritoneal Coccidioidomycosis February 19, 2026A 23-year-old man presented with a 2-month history of unintentional weight loss and worsening abdominal pain and distention. He had recently moved to Arizona from a remote Pacific island.
- Reducing Tobacco Use Worldwide: Tobacco Cessation among Nondaily and Low-Intensity Smokers — Challenges and Opportunities in Latin America February 19, 2026In Latin America, though overall smoking rates have declined, nondaily and low-intensity smoking are increasingly common, and tobacco-cessation resources remain underdeveloped in many countries.
- Subacute Sclerosing Panencephalitis after Measles Infection February 21, 2026
Fortunately, we can choose from 5 active drugs outside of the NRTI class: boosted darunavir (only 2 primary mutations, 33f, 84v), maraviroc, raltegravir, and etravirine. While Fuzeon would also be effective, I would not use an injectable since we have more convenient oral options. This seems like an ideal situation for maraviroc since the virus is CCR5 tropic. I would add two other agents–boosted darunavir and etravirine, saving raltegravir as a back up in case of drug side effect, like etravirine rash.
What I’ve done with similar patients in my practice was to put them on:
1. etravirine
2. maraviroc
3. raltegravir
This adds up to 5 pills twice a day. The patient’s virus(es) has not been exposed to any of these drugs and you do not need to use a PI/r. This has worked great for my patients!